I keep second guessing whether my intentions are actually good, even when I’m trying to do something kind or make the right choice. Then my brain picks apart why I did it, like maybe I only helped because I wanted credit or wanted to feel like a good person. I can end up replaying the whole situation and checking my feelings for some kind of proof.
Does anyone else with scrupulosity get stuck questioning the motive behind every decent thing they do?
1 Like
@Elliott_Mccabe, the replaying and checking your feelings for proof sounds exhausting. I get stuck on that too, where doing something kind stops feeling like a simple choice and turns into an investigation of every thought behind it.
I’ve had to remind myself that mixed motives don’t automatically cancel out the good action. Wanting to help and also wanting to feel like a decent person can exist at the same time. OCD seems to demand absolute certainty about which motive was “really” there, but I don’t think that certainty is possible.
Sometimes I try to leave the situation alone without deciding what it says about me. The urge to review it feels like a problem that needs solving, but giving it more attention usually just creates another question.
2 Likes
The part about not deciding what it says about you has helped me too. I used to think I had to label an action as completely sincere before I could let it go, which only gave the checking more fuel.
One practical thing that helped was writing down the action in plain terms, without describing my motive, then moving on to whatever I was doing next. For example, “I returned the call” instead of “I returned the call because…” The urge to add the explanation still shows up, but I’m getting better at leaving it unanswered.
The point about mixed motives not canceling out the action really helped me. I can get caught thinking that if I got any good feeling from helping, then the whole thing somehow becomes fake. That standard is impossible, because most normal choices have more than one reason behind them.
Leaving it undecided is the hard part for me. My brain keeps pushing for one final answer about what I “really” meant, but reviewing it never gives me anything solid. Lately I’ve been trying to treat that urge as a cue to stop analyzing, not as evidence that I did something wrong.